Difference between revisions of "Governance"

From Dryad wiki
Jump to: navigation, search
(Questions for the Board to consider)
Line 2: Line 2:
  
 
== Members ==
 
== Members ==
 +
Voting members represent societies/journals that have adopted the Joint Data Sharing Policy or its equivalent.
  
 +
Voting:
 +
* Michael Whitlock (American Society of Naturalists)
 +
* Allen Moore (European Society for Evolutionary Biology)
 
* Mohamed Noor (Society for the Study of Evolution)
 
* Mohamed Noor (Society for the Study of Evolution)
* Michael Whitlock (American Society of Naturalists)
+
* Rod Page (Society for Systematic Biology)
 +
 
 +
Non-voting:
 +
* WIlliam Michener or David Baldwin (Ecological Society of America)
 +
 
 +
Voting status TBD:
 +
* TBD (American Institute of Biological Sciences/BioOne)
 +
* TBD (Biological Journal of the Linnean Society of London)
 +
* TBD (Evolutionary Applications)
 +
* Loren Reiseberg (Molecular Ecology)
 +
* Derek Wildman (Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution)
 +
* TBD (Paleontological Society)
 +
* TBD (Proc. Roy Soc. London B)
 +
* TBD (Society for Molecular Biology and Evolution)
 +
* TBD (Society for Integrative and Comparative Biology)
 +
 
 +
Additional journals/societies to contact:
 +
* Journal of Biogeography
 +
* Journal of Morphology
 +
* others TBD
  
 
== Questions for the Board to consider ==
 
== Questions for the Board to consider ==
Line 18: Line 41:
  
 
* Description of the Dryad project overall, what we expect from the board.
 
* Description of the Dryad project overall, what we expect from the board.
* Current status:  
+
* Current status:
 
** Funding and staffing
 
** Funding and staffing
 
** Repository development
 
** Repository development

Revision as of 18:03, 14 August 2008

The Dryad Management Board will oversee the long-term use and development of Dryad. It will consist of representatives from all Dryad partners, including journals, societies, and repositories. There will be one representative from each journal. Societies that publish multiple journals may appoint one representative for each journal or may elect to have a single representative speak for multiple journals.

Members

Voting members represent societies/journals that have adopted the Joint Data Sharing Policy or its equivalent.

Voting:

  • Michael Whitlock (American Society of Naturalists)
  • Allen Moore (European Society for Evolutionary Biology)
  • Mohamed Noor (Society for the Study of Evolution)
  • Rod Page (Society for Systematic Biology)

Non-voting:

  • WIlliam Michener or David Baldwin (Ecological Society of America)

Voting status TBD:

  • TBD (American Institute of Biological Sciences/BioOne)
  • TBD (Biological Journal of the Linnean Society of London)
  • TBD (Evolutionary Applications)
  • Loren Reiseberg (Molecular Ecology)
  • Derek Wildman (Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution)
  • TBD (Paleontological Society)
  • TBD (Proc. Roy Soc. London B)
  • TBD (Society for Molecular Biology and Evolution)
  • TBD (Society for Integrative and Comparative Biology)

Additional journals/societies to contact:

  • Journal of Biogeography
  • Journal of Morphology
  • others TBD

Questions for the Board to consider

  1. What is the long-term funding model for Dryad? Can journals impose page charges sufficient to maintain a repository? Are page charges reasonable for graduate students and other researchers with minimal funding? Can a more permanent governmental funding stream be located (similar to GenBank)?
  2. What policies shall Dryad have regarding embargo?
  3. How should data be cited? At the publication level? At the individual file level? The citation method must be consistent, so as not to skew citation-ranking measures. Dryad can publish suggested citation formats, but each individual journal will have to enforce policies for citations that appear in that journal.
  4. Who takes over as primary contact for a dataset when the corresponding author dies? Should we attempt to keep all corresponding author information current? How?
  5. What does it mean for an author to submit "adequate data"? Are some types of data (e.g., raw instrument readings) too detailed?
  6. What policies should Dryad have regarding the storage of very large data sets? This can include videos, simulation results, genomic data, etc. Should Dryad accept everything and bear all storage costs, raising the amount of base funding needed? Or should large data sets be supported by fees from the author?

Agenda items for the Board's first meeting

  • Description of the Dryad project overall, what we expect from the board.
  • Current status:
    • Funding and staffing
    • Repository development
    • Metadata research
    • Journal interaction
    • Interaction with other Repositories
  • Questions we need answered immediately
  • Set aside time for the board to discuss their own desires? Feature requests, other things board members think the board needs to decide...