Submission System Mockups History

These are outdated versions of the mockups on Submission System Mockups.

2011 March 4 Drafts
1. First page of submission system before user has clicked or entered anything



Comments:

2. New fields appear if the user clicks Published under Select Your Publication Status, also showing horizontal arrangement of publication status



Comments:

3. User is prompted to enter journal title if they click Accepted under Select Your Publication Status, also showing vertical arrangement of publication status



Comments:

4. If the user enters an integrated journal, they are prompted to enter their manuscript number



Comments:

5. If the user enters a non-integrated journal, they must check a box confirming that their manuscript has been accepted



Comments:

6. User is prompted to select journal title from a drop down list and enter their manuscript number if they click In Review under Select Your Publication Status, also showing other publication status options disappearing once one has been clicked (user can click Start Over button if they have made an error)



Comments:

7. Planning for future ability to allow data submission to Dryad before manuscript submission to journal, here shown behaving the same as the manuscript in review workflow (that is, with a limited drop down list of journals for which this is allowed)



Comments:

2011 February 24 Drafts
1. First page of submission system before user has clicked or entered anything



Comments:


 * 1) This mockup is based on feedback from the Feb 21 all hands that choice of publication status should come before journal title entry, in part because entering a DOI or PMID would allow lookup of journal title. --Elenafeinstein 18:32, 24 February 2011 (EST)

2. New fields appear if the user clicks Published under Select Your Publication Status



Comments:


 * 1) When a user enters a DOI or PMID, we plan to use it to create a pre-populated submission, similar to those created via integration. Do we want a user in this situation to proceed directly to their pre-populated submission once they click Next at the bottom of this page, or do we want to insert an additional page (or insert something into this page) that shows them the proposed matching article and asks whether this is correct? --Elenafeinstein 18:32, 24 February 2011 (EST)

3. User is prompted to enter journal title if they click Accepted under Select Your Publication Status



Comments:

4. If the user enters an integrated journal, they are prompted to enter their manuscript number



Comments:

5. If the user enters a non-integrated journal, they must check a box confirming that their manuscript has been accepted



Comments:

6. User is prompted to select journal title from a drop down list and enter their manuscript number if they click In Review under Select Your Publication Status



Comments:


 * 1) Do we want to go ahead and limit their choices with a drop down list of journals, or let the user enter any journal and then display a message if the journal they enter doesn't use Dryad at the review stage? --Elenafeinstein 18:32, 24 February 2011 (EST)
 * 2) Is it an undesirable inconsistency that the manuscript number entry field and the journal selection are both active at the same time here, but are sequential for accepted manuscripts (the above three mockups)? --Elenafeinstein 18:34, 24 February 2011 (EST)